Vecchi Group InternationalExpert Witness · Threat Consulting & Training
Expert Witness

Negligent Security Expert Witness

Negligent security cases turn on two questions: was the violence foreseeable, and were the security measures reasonable? Dr. Gregory M. Vecchi, a retired FBI Supervisory Special Agent and former Unit Chief of the FBI Behavioral Science Unit, helps attorneys answer both with a structured, defensible analysis.

Scope

What the analysis addresses

  • Whether warning behaviors and prior incidents made the violence foreseeable
  • Whether security measures were reasonable for the known risks
  • How the offender's pathway to violence relates to the alleged security failures
  • Whether different measures would likely have prevented or interrupted the attack
Cases

Typical matters

Dr. Vecchi is retained in premises liability and negligent security cases involving shootings, stabbings, assaults, and other targeted violence at:

  • Apartment complexes and hotels
  • Retail stores, restaurants, bars, and nightclubs
  • Parking lots and garages
  • Workplaces and office buildings
  • Schools, universities, and healthcare facilities
  • Rideshare and transportation settings
Records

What we review

A defensible opinion starts with the record. Depending on the matter, the review includes police reports and calls for service, prior incident and crime data for the property, security policies, post orders, and staffing records, video, witness statements, and deposition testimony, and the communications and conduct of the offender before the incident. Each piece is weighed against what the property owner or security provider knew, or should have known, at the time.

Method

Our approach

The analysis uses structured professional judgment and the Targeted Violence Stairway Model. It follows the published guidance and best practices of ATAP, the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI, and the U.S. Secret Service, and ASIS International standards and guidelines. The focus is accuracy: avoiding both false positives and false negatives.

We work with both plaintiff and defense counsel. The same method is applied to every case, whichever side retains us.

Experience

Why Dr. Vecchi

  • 50+ criminal and civil matters as a consulting or testifying expert, for both plaintiffs and defendants
  • 100% Daubert record: certified as an expert in every challenge (2020 and 2022)
  • Former Unit Chief, FBI Behavioral Science Unit, Quantico
  • Lead author of Fatal Grievances: Forecasting and Preventing Active Killer Threats in School, Campus, and Workplace Settings (Routledge, 2023)
  • Most matters resolve before deposition or trial on the strength of the analysis and the written report
FAQ

Common questions

Is a crime on the property foreseeable just because crime happened nearby?

Not by itself. The analysis looks at the type, frequency, and similarity of prior incidents, what the owner knew, and whether the specific offender showed warning behaviors, rather than relying on neighborhood crime statistics alone.

Do you offer opinions on security staffing and measures?

Yes. Opinions address whether the measures in place were reasonable for the known risks, measured against ASIS International standards and guidelines, and whether different measures would likely have prevented or interrupted the attack.

Can you consult before we decide whether to designate you?

Yes. Dr. Vecchi serves as both a consulting expert and a testifying expert.

Discuss your case

Tell us about the matter and the issues in dispute. All inquiries are confidential.

Contact Us