Foreseeability of Violence Expert Witness
Foreseeability is often the deciding issue in violence-related litigation, and it is often argued with hindsight. Dr. Vecchi evaluates it the way threat assessors do in practice: by asking what was known, or knowable, before the incident, and where the person stood on the pathway to violence at the time.
What we examine
- Warning behaviors and concerning communications before the incident
- What the organization knew, and what it should have recognized
- Whether the person was moving along the pathway to violence
- Whether the response was reasonable given what was known at the time
How targeted violence develops
Targeted violence is rarely sudden. Research and casework from the FBI and the U.S. Secret Service show that most attackers move through recognizable stages: a grievance, ideas about violence, research and planning, preparation, and finally the attack. Along the way, many show warning behaviors that someone noticed, such as threats, leakage of intent, fixation on a target, or changes in behavior. The Targeted Violence Stairway Model gives the court a clear way to see where a person stood on that path, and what a reasonable organization could have recognized, at each point in time.
Where the question arises
- Workplace violence and employer liability
- School and university violence
- Healthcare and patient-on-staff violence
- Premises liability and negligent security
- Domestic and intimate partner violence that spills into the workplace or public places
- Police and security practices
An accurate account, not a convenient one
We work to avoid false positives that overstate a risk and false negatives that dismiss a real one. Opinions rest on structured professional judgment and the Targeted Violence Stairway Model, consistent with the published guidance of ATAP, DHS, the FBI, and the U.S. Secret Service, and ASIS International standards and guidelines.
We work with plaintiff and defense counsel.
Why Dr. Vecchi
- 50+ criminal and civil matters as a consulting or testifying expert, for both plaintiffs and defendants
- 100% Daubert record: certified as an expert in every challenge (2020 and 2022)
- Former Unit Chief, FBI Behavioral Science Unit, Quantico
- Lead author of Fatal Grievances: Forecasting and Preventing Active Killer Threats in School, Campus, and Workplace Settings (Routledge, 2023)
- Most matters resolve before deposition or trial on the strength of the analysis and the written report
Common questions
Isn't foreseeability just hindsight?
That is the risk the analysis is built to avoid. Opinions are limited to what was known, or reasonably knowable, before the incident, assessed with the same methods threat assessment teams use in real time.
What do the opinions rest on?
The professional standards of behavioral threat assessment and management, structured professional judgment, and the Targeted Violence Stairway Model. Reports are prepared to meet the requirements of Federal Rule of Evidence 702.
Has Dr. Vecchi been challenged under Daubert?
Yes, and he was certified as an expert in every challenge (2020 and 2022).
Discuss your case
Tell us about the matter and the issues in dispute. All inquiries are confidential.
Contact Us